Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Eat the Best, Eat Homemade at AJ’s Burgers

AJ’s Burgers is real food and real people putting it together with passion and love. We offer a contemporary American and Italian menu in a relaxed, friendly setting in the heart of New Rochelle.


Our mission is to serve great burgers, freshly cut fries and the thickest shakes ever!  And so much more.  Our menu offerings are a mix of regional, seasonal American dishes, seafood, creative sandwiches, BBQ, hearty salads, and Italian classics.  We strive to prepare clean & tasty food from the freshest natural ingredients. Almost everything is homemade from scratch. We know that you work hard for your money, we offer genuinely good value.

When you explore our menu, don’t miss AJ's EZ meals and catering options.  AJ's EZ Meals are super affordable healthy dinners.   Take a break, order for the week, and let us do the shopping, cooking, and cleaning that goes into every meal.

We are located across the street from City Hall, 542 North Avenue in New Rochelle, convenient to  I-95 and the Hutchinson River Parkway.  Parking is easy in the municipal lot. 

We are excited to offer a local neighborhood restaurant to call your own.   Find out why AJ’s has been voted the best burger and the best Italian restaurant by Trip Advisor.  Order online or stop by soon. We are very glad you are here. 

Mariano's Challenge

Mariano Rivera came in with his brother, Joe, and asked for the best seafood dish we could come up with.  AJ took on the challenge by preparing lobster and shrimp positano,  a tasty classic of lobster tail, shrimp, arugula, butter and fresh tomatoes over linguine.  Its always on our menu now, try it when you are have a taste for something special! 

Another local celeb is our friend, Chuck Zito, actor, boxer, martial artist, and stuntman, (and former president of the NY Hell’s Angels!)  You might catch him here enjoying a burger or slider and fries, keeping his energy up for the next ride.

Why our burgers are soo good

AJ’s burgers are made from a proprietary blend of quality beef from a local manufacturer who distributes daily.  It is always made in small batches and tested before it goes out. The burgers are formed by hand and char-grilled. Toppings are cut fresh daily.  The Chef’s Favorite selection always include the Club Burger and Habanero Burger, Hudson Regional Winners two years in a row.   Our eight ounce burgers are a meal, if you prefer a smaller bite, look for the new quarter pound burger, or ask for just as many sliders as you like.  Whatever your burger craving, we’ve got you covered!

More than just burgers

While Italian food is not the focus at AJ's, AJ has incorporated some of his key dishes including delicious thin crust pizza (when available), eggplant and chicken parmigiana made with his classic homemade marinara sauce. Trying the pizza is a must (only made on special nights) ; we offer a twelve inch, thin crust pie following a recipe that's been passed down through generations. The pizza is mouthwatering with just the right amount of garlic and the choices are extensive. The family favorite is the Buffalo Chicken Pizza topped with crispy fried onion strings and served with a side of our homemade creamy gorgonzola dressing.